Posted by: duskfire | May 5, 2012

Ubuntu 12.04, a review

Ubuntu has been one of the top two distributions in Linux for a very long time, yet this is the first time I have really used Ubuntu for more than a week. I prefer Linux Mint, which is derived from Ubuntu.

I used the 32-bit version of 12.04 LTS for this review. Some people have questioned why the default is to recommend the 32 bit version, but I have to agree with this decision. There are still a few points when running Linux where 64 bit versions will hit minor snags. They aren’t things that intermediate Linux users can’t fix, but people who are just starting out on Ubuntu will appreciate having fewer problems.

Ubuntu 12.04 with Software Center open

The installation was straightforward and doesn’t intimidate, and I appreciated the presence of an option box to check whether you want to install codecs right then, instead of doing it later. Linux Mint just goes ahead and installs them by default. Your user password strength is indicated, and my wireless security key was carried over from the live session.

I think the default wallpaper is quite ugly, and switched it as soon as I could. Luckily, you have quite a few choices in the Appearance section of the System Settings application. That is also where you adjust how wide the Unity bar is on the left side of the screen.

Unity and HUD

Unity was created by Ubuntu, their vision of a desktop user interface that can be (hopefully) used on tablets. The first time that I tried to use it was in its infancy with the 11.04 edition, Natty Narwhal. After 2 days, I’d had enough and returned to what is now termed the “fallback” session. I also installed a couple of other desktops, Xfce and KDE.

At this point though, I have to admit that Unity works. There are a number of small annoyances I still have, but it has improved greatly. Whether or not you like using it will be an individual matter, and I’ll just say that you should try it for awhile before deciding that it isn’t suited for you. There’s a lot of things that are done differently than in GNOME 3 and the now obsolete GNOME 2, and a “first time user” guide would really help. There are some sections of the Ubuntu website that show you what the features are, and yet I felt it was still not easy to find all the information on Unity in a single area. (Salix OS, a much less popular distribution, provides a Starter Guide for their distribution in 6 languages, either as a downloadable PDF or an online version.)

The Unity sidebar can hold 21 icons at size 32 (the smallest) before the last few start to flatten. They are easy to pull off and move to a different spot on the bar, and you can lock any open application with a single click. If you scroll your mouse, the bar moves up to let you access the last ones more easily. You have very few customization options unless you install programs such as MyUnity or Gnome Tweak Tool (called Advanced Settings), both available in the Software Center. Also found there are a number of apps such as an alarm clock, a weather app, and other little useful items.

a few of the applets you can get for Unity

The Dash – When you click the top icon on the bar, or just hold your “super” key (usually the Windows symbol key) briefly, the Dash comes up. This lists recent applications, recent files, and recent downloads, and has an area to search for things you need, in a similar way to GNOME Shell. This search area is known as a Lens, and you can add several more that have been made especially for uses like Wikipedia, Youtube, Spotify, even Flickr. (There’s one for Grooveshark too, and I may have to check that out).

The Dash in Unity

The HUD – The Heads Up Display is activated with your Alt key. This brings up a different set of choices than the Dash does, and the list varies depending on what applications you have open – HUD tries to match your search with the menus on all open programs, with somewhat mixed results. In the picture below, you can faintly see that I have both Firefox and a Terminal open.

Using the HUD in Unity

Both the HUD and the Dash notably avoid using the mouse. A lot of power users of Linux insist that keeping both hands on the keyboard is more efficient than moving one from the keyboard to the mouse, moving the mouse around the desktop, then returning that hand back to the keyboard.

I think learning how to use the Dash and the HUD effectively will take some practice; The HUD especially seemed to have trouble guessing my meaning, but that is undoubtedly because I don’t fully understand the best ways to use it.

Holding down the “super” key will give you a nice list of shortcuts (because there’s no way you’d remember them all):

Software

When you first start Ubuntu 12.04 after installation, the sidebar holds your home folder, the Firefox browser, 3 LibreOffice programs (Writer, Calc, Impress), the Ubuntu Software Center, a link to the Ubuntu One cloud storage, System Settings, and the Update Manager.

There’s an icon called Workspace Switcher below all of these, which will let you move between the 4 default virtual workspaces. I give Ubuntu credit for making sure this useful utility is on the bar. I have used some Linux distributions where you are set up with 2 or 4 virtual workspaces, yet because it doesn’t show on the taskbar, I didn’t realize immediately that I had more than one ready to use.

Also included are the Rhythmbox music player, the Gnome movie player, Gwibber (social media client), several games, Thunderbird (the Mozilla mail client), and about 60 other programs. There is no IRC client installed by default, unlike some distributions. Is this because Ubuntu thinks that its users no longer use IRC? [edit 5/18: Apparently the Empathy IM client also includes an IRC capability. I don't use Empathy, so I didn't realize this]

At the bottom is the Trash icon.

With the media codecs installed, all my favorite media sites worked perfectly – Apple movie trailers, Hulu, Grooveshark, and Youtube.

The Java JRE is not installed by default. The file that allows you to watch DVDs (libdvdcss) is not available without enabling a 3rd party repository,

As you can see in this picture, there are a large number of games readily available through the Software Center. Ubuntu seems to strongly encourage you to use their Software Center, and hasn’t included the standard package manager for most Debian-based Linux versions (Synaptic) by default, although you can still add it later. Emulators, DOSbox, and Wine can be installed using the Software Center as well. I think that a few games which are not quite as well known are only in the regular repositories and you’ll need to install Synaptic to find and install them. Surprisingly, “FPS” and “strategy” games aren’t given their own categories at the top.

Things I like -

Ubuntu is, for the most part, a solid and trustworthy distribution. The Software Center is very well put together and looks great. I approve of Ubuntu selling games and magazines via the Center. The perception that Linux users will never pay for good applications is false, but the myth may be holding back some developers from making a version of their software for Linux.

Installing a few casual games by default always gets appreciation from me. I have said many times, all distributions aimed at home users ought to be doing this.

The Firefox browser is prepopulated with a few Ubuntu related websites.

Ubuntu easily detected my HP wireless printer and added it, using the HPLIP library rather than CUPS. I didn’t even have to choose which HP printer from a list.

Things I don’t like -

In any browser that puts its menu up on the top Unity bar, you cannot right click to perform operations on the bookmarks. This is, for Firefox, a major change in expected behavior and it only happens when using the Unity desktop.

The reliance on Unity as the primary desktop means that if you ever move away from Ubuntu, you have to learn one of the others. This is because only a handful of other distributions are using Unity as their default desktop, and none of them are well known.

For gamers, the Getdeb unofficial repository with extra games is not included by default as it is in Mint. Also, I was surprised to discover that in the Software Center, the featured game Battle for Wesnoth has an outdated link to version 1.8, which is no longer in the repositories! Version 1.10 is available but doesn’t show unless you search for “wesnoth”. I hope that there aren’t any other popular applications that have this issue. I suspect that because 1.8 has more reviews, it shows up on the front page of Games. But the link to install the file ought to either find the current one, or provide a message such as “there is a newer version of this game/application available. Would you like to install it?”.

There are a few minor quirks that I didn’t expect from Ubuntu. The worst is that when shutting it down, it sometime hangs before powering off, and I have to turn off the laptop manually. I don’t know whether it’s doing this on other laptops, but I have never had this issue with any version of Linux before.

Final Thoughts

Even though I still prefer Linux Mint, I’ll admit that Ubuntu is definitely a very well put together distribution. Everything worked as expected and of course they have the huge Debian repository base to draw from. Most people will find it to be just fine, and again I will say – don’t decide that Unity is not for you without giving it a try. I prefer using KDE, the regular GNOME Shell, or Cinnamon, but Linux is all about choices. There are plenty of people who really like Unity. If it does bother you, you can add the KDE, Xfce, LXDE or Cinnamon desktops to Ubuntu, or just use the GNOME Shell.

(Cinnamon is not available in the main repositories, you’ll have to add a third party trusted repository. Instructions on how to do this can be found at OMG Ubuntu, or Webupd8, whose sites are listed below)

Because of Ubuntu’s popularity, there are several websites devoted to it that feature advice, and tips on getting the best use of Unity, or customizing it where possible. If you decide to install Ubuntu for a friend or relative, you should definitely read them. Some of the more useful are:

OMG Ubuntu

Webupd8

Ubuntu guide (a wiki)

Full Circle (a magazine also available in the Software Center)

About these ads

Responses

  1. Great review Duskfire!

    Just one small problem: your image of the HUD is actually the Dash. You can see a good image for the HUD in action here: http://www.ubuntu.com/ubuntu/whats-new

    Keep up the good work.

    • Thanks for catching that! I have fixed it.

  2. Thanks for an unbiased review but, sadly, Unity isn’t for me. I kissed Ubuntu good-bye with Mint 11 and have never looked back. Mint is the perfect “fit” for me.

  3. Awesome. I installed it on my netbook and it works like a charm too. Too bad it is not working too great with external display. My review is here – http://mobilityupdate.com/linux/ubuntu-12-04-review-netbook/

  4. Great review. I have it installed on my Toshiba L755D-S5204 laptop and it’s working great! You can find my review here: http://xjonquilx.co.cc/2012/04/29/ubuntu-12-04-still-alive-still-kicking/

  5. like ubuntu HATE disappearing application menus

  6. I find it hard to find settings for applications. A really poor design choice
    at first glance.

  7. all unity top bar right clicks fail – so there are no About splash screens for the short cut icons to identify them ie. NetworkManager and so each left click drop down menu is additionally crammed with remmanents previously available by a right click – IRRITATING beacuse this severly cripples and impacts on the right context of ANY & ALL drop down menus originating on the top bar such as FireFox – FireFox run in safe-mode will disenagage it’s File Edit … toolbar from the top and put it back in the window and restore right click functionality but this limits FF in other ways AND most aps do not come with safe-mode escape routes and must succomb to the vagaries of the host (in this case HOSTILE) environment -


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 27 other followers

%d bloggers like this: